
How One Murder Changed Native American Reservations Forever
Season 4 Episode 2 | 10m 50sVideo has Closed Captions
After seizing the Black Hills, the US used a murder case to expand its power over Native nations.
In 1883, Lakota man Crow Dog killed a rival tribal leader and was sentenced to hang by an all-white jury in Deadwood, a town built on illegally seized Lakota land in the Black Hills. After appealing to the Supreme Court, he was released when the Court ruled the federal government lacked jurisdiction. Congress responded with the Major Crimes Act of 1885, expanding federal power over Native tribes.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Funding for ROGUE HISTORY is provided by the Corporation for Public Broadcasting.

How One Murder Changed Native American Reservations Forever
Season 4 Episode 2 | 10m 50sVideo has Closed Captions
In 1883, Lakota man Crow Dog killed a rival tribal leader and was sentenced to hang by an all-white jury in Deadwood, a town built on illegally seized Lakota land in the Black Hills. After appealing to the Supreme Court, he was released when the Court ruled the federal government lacked jurisdiction. Congress responded with the Major Crimes Act of 1885, expanding federal power over Native tribes.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Rogue History
Rogue History is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship- When Crow Dog shot and killed his rival, Spotted Tail, he didn't know his personal conflict would become a stand-in for conflict between nations.
The Lakota people quickly held him accountable for the death and resolved the matter, but the US government felt their justice system was the only correct one, and they dragged Crow Dog hundreds of miles away from his home reservation to stand trial for murder.
12 white jurors sentenced him to death.
So who had jurisdiction?
Just a few years earlier, the ground Crow Dog stood on had belonged to his people.
The United States had already taken the Black Hills from the Lakota, and now they wanted control of the reservations too, but they underestimated just how hard Crow Dog was willing to fight back.
I'm Joel Cook, and this is "Rogue History."
This season of "Rogue History" is brought to you by "Crime and Punishment in America," a new four-part documentary from PBS.
There's no question that Crow Dog committed murder, but what actually happened between him and Spotted Tail?
Well, these guys had political beef for years.
It likely started in 1876 when Spotted Tail was one of the signers of the agreement that ceded the Black Hills to the US.
But even though Spotted Tail was a chief, it wasn't his decision alone.
You see, the Brule Lakota band has a distributed power structure where instead of a single leader, each extended family group has a leader that participates in a council.
The council makes decisions that affect the whole band by consensus.
Spotted Tail was one of these leaders, and Crow Dog also played a role in negotiations with the US government over the Black Hills territory, the land where the Lakota lived for centuries.
More than any other council member, Spotted Tail was willing to accommodate American wishes.
He agreed to send Lakota children to a residential boarding school, which forced them to assimilate to white culture.
Rumors were also floating around about him pocketing the fees white ranchers paid for grazing their cattle on Lakota land.
When Crow Dog called him out, Spotted Tail tried to get Crow Dog fired from his job as tribal police chief.
For months, the two men made threats of violence back and forth until finally, Crow Dog shot and killed his rival.
But even if Spotted Tail was breaking tribal norms, murder was not an acceptable response in Lakota culture.
So the council had to figure out how to handle what Crow Dog had done.
To be clear, not all Native nations handled conflict the same way, then or now.
In the Cherokee nation, for example, an action like Crow Dog's would've merited revenge.
Someone from the victim's family would be expected to kill either the murderer or someone from their family.
A single act of violence could set off a cycle of bloodshed and retaliation until Cherokee leaders created a new set of laws in the early 1800s to stop it.
The Lakota system at this point in time was totally different, rooted in a concept that today we might call restorative justice.
The emphasis is more on healing for the victims over punishment of the offender.
The tribal council analyzed the relationships that had been damaged between Crow Dog and Spotted Tail's families, between Crow Dog and the council, and between Crow Dog and the community as a whole.
The goal of this process was to repair these relationships and restore social balance.
Peacemakers worked with Crow Dog and Spotted Tail's families to figure out appropriate restitution.
Crow Dog was instructed to give gifts of $600, eight horses, and a blanket to Spotted Tail's family, which would be at least a five-figure payment today.
This compensation also carried symbolic weight as a way for Crow Dog to acknowledge the harm he'd done.
He made his amends, and that's where the whole thing could have ended.
But there was a new sheriff in town, like, literally.
And unlike the Lakota system, the United States believed only the government had the authority to impose punishment for crimes.
A murder in the US, especially at this time, would be punished with imprisonment or execution, not restitution and reconciliation.
The US had even established their own government agency to help them exercise their authority over tribal lands, the Bureau of Indian Affairs, and they may not have been too happy about Crow Dog killing the person who was helping them encroach on Lakota territory.
Even though he had already completed the Lakota restitution process, Bureau of Indian Affairs agents quickly arrested and turned him over to the Dakota territory authorities.
But the arrest was part of a bigger gambit.
Establishing federal jurisdiction over Lakota territory would be the first step to full control over the reservations.
There's nothing surprising about Americans stealing land from Native peoples, but why so much fuss over the Black Hills specifically?
This land called Paha Sapa in Lakota has been inhabited by Indigenous people for so long that the Lakota believed it to be the place where they were created.
It has often been described by modern Lakota writers as the womb of Mother Earth, and sacred sites like Six Grandfathers dot the landscape.
The first encroachment on the Black Hills was a trailway in the early 1800s, which the Americans requested so that settlers heading west could pass through safely.
The US even entered a treaty with Plains Nations to allow these transportation routes in 1851, but give them an inch and you know the rest.
Settlers kept staying on the land instead of passing through.
So they came to the table again in 1868 to sign a second Fort Laramie Treaty.
In this version, the US established the boundaries of the Great Sioux Reservation, which includes the Black Hills.
The Lakota would continue to allow safe passage through their territory.
In return, the US agreed to recognize Lakota ownership of the land and protect the reservation from an authorized settlement by US citizens.
So, everyone agrees.
The Black Hills belong to the Lakota, right?
Well, just a few years after the ink dried on the treaty, the federal government sent Lieutenant Colonel George Custer on a military expedition through the Black Hills.
They were supposed to find a good spot for a military fort and establish a good route of passage.
And they found that, but they also found gold.
Word got out, and prospectors rushed in to establish mining camps.
Once they found an especially rich deposit, those camps turned into a settlement.
And within two years, as many as 10,000 settlers formed a town called Deadwood, complete with a mayor, a sheriff, and a local newspaper, and future site of Crow Dog's trial.
Even though the Fort Laramie Treaty said the US was supposed to protect Lakota territory, in reality, they did the exact opposite.
The US tried to resolve the situation by offering cold, hard cash for the Black Hills.
But for some weird reason, the Lakota refused to sell their sacred, cherished land.
And America isn't great at taking no for an answer, so they decided to take it by force.
In June of 1876, the US planned to attack a Lakota and Cheyenne encampment, but Lakota leaders, Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse, were ready, with warriors of their own.
Custer died in the fight, known in the US sources as the Battle of Little Bighorn, and to the Lakota, as the Battle of Greasy Grass.
But the Plains Tribe's victory didn't last.
The US returned with more troops and more violence to force the Lakota to sign the Black Hills over to the US in October of 1876.
In the end, the US government commissioned the faces of four US presidents carved into the side of Six Grandfathers and renamed it Mount Rushmore.
The Lakota saw this as the ultimate symbol of imposing US government values onto Lakota land.
So all these decades of conflict and conquest explained why Crow Dog saw Spotted Tail's accommodation of the US as an existential threat to the Black Hills and the Lakota nation.
When the US stepped in to arrest Crow Dog in 1881, it was about refusing to acknowledge the Lakota justice system and Lakota sovereignty.
When Crow Dog was sentenced to death by hanging, he argued that the US law enforcement did not have the right to arrest him in the first place and appealed his conviction all the way to the Supreme Court.
The court ruled nine to zero in favor of Crow Dog, confirming that the US did not have jurisdiction to try crime between Lakota people on Lakota land.
Crow Dog was released and returned to the reservation where he remained until his death in 1912.
And so the Lakota finally were able to govern their land and the US never imposed their will on them ever again.
Just kidding.
Two years after Crow Dog's Supreme Court case, Congress passed the Major Crimes Act, giving the federal government authority to prosecute serious crimes like murder, rape, assault, arson, and burglary committed by Native people on tribal lands.
But if the Major Crimes Act gave the US government jurisdiction over tribal lands, what about tribal jurisdiction?
Well, it's a complicated and ongoing legal gray area that continues to be reinterpreted by courts today.
In 1978, in Oliphant versus Suquamish Indian Tribe, the Supreme Court ruled that tribal courts don't have jurisdiction to prosecute crimes committed by non-Native people on Native lands.
Many experts agree that this has led to the contemporary crisis of missing and murdered Indigenous women and relatives.
Because of the relative impunity that US citizens have on tribal lands, Native nations have struggled to obtain justice for crimes committed against Native women, 88% of which are perpetrated by non-Native people.
The US still controls the Black Hills, and the Major Crimes Act still limits tribal jurisdiction on their land.
So how can this ongoing conflict be resolved?
The two nations' differing philosophies of justice bear out in their proposed solutions.
The Lakota have spent decades pursuing the return of the Black Hills, claiming that US settlements on that land violated the 1868 treaty.
After the Supreme Court agreed that the United States did violate the Fort Laramie Treaty, the US offered payment for the Black Hills in 1980, but the Lakota still refused payment, asserting the land was never for sale in the first place.
In 2023, the ACLU and Lakota People's Law Project published a report that stated that the only way to repair the relationship between nations would be to honor the original treaty, return the Black Hills to the Lakota, and restore their millennia-old relationship to the land.
It remains to be seen whether that will happen.
And if you wanna learn more about restorative justice, check out "Crime and Punishment in America," a new four-part documentary series that tells the sweeping story of our criminal justice system from the colonial era to today.
(gentle ambient music)
Support for PBS provided by:
Funding for ROGUE HISTORY is provided by the Corporation for Public Broadcasting.
















